Paul Dottin
Robinson Crusoe examin'd and criticis'd : Or, a new edition of Charles Gildon's famous pamphlet now published with an introduction and explanatory notes, together with an essay on Gildon's life
London & Paris: J.M. Dent and Sons LTD, 1923.
This is the most influential piece of Gildon scholarship--Dottin's life of Gildon has been cited by every piece of scholarship since. This work contains a critical edition of Gilon's famous pamphlet attacking Defoe's Robinson Crusoe, a life of Gildon, and a list of works Dottin believed were published by Gildon.